Revenge of the Playlist Meme! As I can't edit posts after a certain period of time without them doubleposting on abeybaby, I just decided to doublepost for everyone!

Switching out the correctly answered lyrics:

1. "In the Drink," BNL -- Allison D
   
2. "We're Not Sorry," Urinetown -- Clare, Renata,
   
3. "Hello Mr. Zebra," Tori Amos -- Renata, Allison D
   
4. "Happiness is a Warm Gun," The Beatles -- Renata
   
5. Half a prayer, half a song; thou hast always been with me though we have been always apart. (Brenna should know, at least. Mom and Dad should know this!)
   
6. "Eclipse," Pink Floyd -- Jume
   
7. If you can do the Bart, then you're bad like Michael Jackson (come on, Rebecca! I know you know this! It was on the CD you burned for me!)
   
8. "There's No Business Like Show Business," Annie Get Your Gun -- Daddy
   
9. Everybody seems to think I'm lazy. I don't mind, I think they're crazy. (close, kids)
   
10. "Little Earthquakes," Tori Amos -- Renata, Clare
    
11. "I Know," BNL -- Renata, Allison D
    
12. I'm offensive, I'm a bigot, I'm a fraud, can you dig it? I'm a sexist, racist, homophobic, fat, pathetic putz. (*) (It's been played on Air America, if that helps)
    
13. "Another Brick in the Wall," Pink Floyd -- Renata, Allison D
    
14. Some boys take dirty books to the john and give themselves a whack. I did the same with lithographs of thumbscrews and the rack. (*) (I've blogged about this song. It's a bonus track for a new Broadway cast revival recording of one of my favourite shows. It's from an early draft of the show.)
    
15. "Jackie's Strength," Tori Amos -- Clare
    
16. Better than rain or rippling brook is a mug of beer inside this Took! (can you be more specific, Meghan? BTW, you guys are so lame for not getting this one. XD)
    
17. I'm tired of having to sing everything! Can't we just talk? (*) (Aaron should know this one)
    
18. "Mad World," Gary Jules/Tears for Fears/that song at the end of Donnie Darko -- Clare, Renata, Ko
    
19. In volitaile market, only stable investment is porn! (close, kids, but no cigar! try again!)
    
20. "Big-Ass Rock," The Full Monty -- Renata, Ko
    
21. "Cool," West Side Story -- Ko
    
22. "I've Got a Theory," Once More, With Feeling! (the Buffy musical) -- Clare, Renata, Meghan, Allison D
    
23. "Perfectly Marvelous," Cabaret -- Renata
    
24. (Translated from Romanian) I was born in a gypsy camp, in a glade in the wood. I was a rambler since childhood, like all the gypsies. But, you see, one day, I was stolen from my mom by the aliens. (*) (come to think of it, I don't think any of you guys that read my blog nowadays could recognize it, though I know I've played it for Ko. Matt and Luke introduced me Senior year.)
    
25. "Defying Gravity," Wicked -- Clare, Renata, Allison D

I'll post the full answers tomorrow morning. In the meantime, keep guessing!